Seeking Retirement
Back to Blog

Sequence of Returns Risk: The Retirement Threat Nobody Talks About

Nov 13 2026

Sequence of Returns Risk: The Retirement Threat Nobody Talks About

By SR Staff

Imagine two retirees with identical nest eggs, identical spending, and identical average investment returns over a decade. Ten years later, one has more money than she started with, and the other has lost a meaningful chunk of his savings. How is that possible? The answer is sequence of returns risk, and it may be the most underappreciated danger in retirement planning.

While you're working and saving, the order of your returns barely matters. Once you start withdrawing money, it suddenly matters a lot. Here's how sequence of returns risk works, why the first few years of retirement are so important, and what you can do to protect yourself.

What Is Sequence of Returns Risk?

Sequence of returns risk is the danger that poor market returns arrive early in retirement, right when you begin drawing down your portfolio. When the market drops and you're still pulling out money to live on, you're forced to sell investments at low prices. Those shares are gone for good, so they can't participate in the recovery.

During your working years, it works the other way. If you're adding money to a 401(k) during a downturn, you're buying shares on sale. As long as you don't need to sell, a bad year early on and a bad year later on lead to the same ending balance over the same period. Withdrawals change the math entirely.

That's why many planners call the five years before and the five to ten years after your retirement date the "retirement red zone." It's the window when your portfolio is typically at its largest and your exposure to a poorly timed market decline is greatest.

A Simple Example: Same Returns, Very Different Outcomes

Let's make this concrete with a hypothetical illustration. Two retirees each start with $1 million and withdraw $50,000 at the beginning of every year. Over 10 years, both earn the exact same set of annual returns, averaging about 6.1% per year. The only difference is the order.

After 10 years, Retiree A is left with roughly $854,000. Retiree B has about $1.17 million. That's a gap of more than $300,000, created entirely by luck of timing. And if neither retiree had been taking withdrawals, they would have ended up with exactly the same balance. This example is simplified and doesn't reflect any particular investment, but it shows why the early years carry so much weight.

This is also why the famous 4% rule is built around worst-case starting years. Researchers designed it to survive retirements that began just before major downturns, because those are the scenarios that drain portfolios fastest.

5 Ways to Protect Yourself From Sequence Risk

You can't control when the market drops. You can control how vulnerable your plan is when it does. These strategies aren't mutually exclusive, and many retirees combine several of them.

  1. Build a cash or bond buffer. Keeping one to three years of planned withdrawals in cash, CDs, or short-term bonds means you don't have to sell stocks during a downturn. You spend from the buffer while your stock holdings have time to recover, then refill it when markets improve.
  2. Stay flexible with spending. Rigid, inflation-adjusted withdrawals are the most vulnerable to sequence risk. "Guardrail" approaches, like the one developed by financial planner Jonathan Guyton, CFP, trim withdrawals modestly after bad years and allow raises after good ones. Even a temporary 10% spending cut, such as skipping a big trip, can meaningfully improve a portfolio's longevity.
  3. Consider a "bond tent." Research by retirement income experts Wade Pfau, PhD, CFA, and Michael Kitces, CFP, suggests that holding more bonds around your retirement date, then gradually shifting back toward stocks over time, can reduce the damage of an early downturn. The idea is to be most conservative when you're most exposed.
  4. Be strategic about which accounts you tap. In a down year, drawing from cash, bonds, or accounts that held up better can help you avoid selling stocks at a loss. Our guide to the best order to withdraw from retirement accounts explains how to balance this with taxes.
  5. Create guaranteed income to cover the basics. The more of your essential expenses that are covered by Social Security, a pension, or an annuity, the less you need to pull from investments when markets fall. For many people, delaying Social Security to secure a larger lifetime benefit is one of the most effective ways to reduce long-term pressure on a portfolio.

Other Ways to Buy Yourself Time

Beyond portfolio tactics, a few life decisions can soften the blow of a poorly timed market. Working part-time for the first few years of retirement, even earning modest income, can significantly reduce how much you need to withdraw while markets recover. Delaying your retirement date by a year or two during a downturn can have a similar effect, though that's a personal decision with tradeoffs that go beyond money.

It also helps to know your numbers before you need them. If you've mapped out a retirement paycheck that separates essential expenses from discretionary ones, you'll already know which costs can bend in a bad year. That makes it much easier to stay calm instead of making emotional decisions, like selling everything at the bottom.

Finally, remember that sequence risk is about the combination of withdrawals and timing, not about the market in general. A downturn ten or fifteen years into retirement usually does far less damage, because your portfolio has had time to grow and your remaining time horizon is shorter.

The Bottom Line

Sequence of returns risk means that when you experience bad markets can matter as much as how your investments perform on average. The first decade of retirement deserves special attention, because losses paired with withdrawals in those years can be hard to undo.

The good news is that this risk is manageable. A cash buffer, flexible spending, a thoughtful asset allocation, and reliable income sources can all help your plan withstand a rough start. If you're within five years of retirement, now is the time to stress-test your plan for a bad first few years. Consider reviewing it with a fee-only financial planner who can model different scenarios based on your specific situation.

Written by: Seeking Retirement

Find more great articles on these retirement topics